Stainless steel deep drawing defects: wrinkles, tears, earing and springback
A successful draw is a balance between material, tool and press. When that balance breaks, defects appear; each has a cause and a remedy.
The draw ratio
The ratio between blank diameter and punch diameter measures the strain asked of the material. For austenitic stainless steel, it is around 2 for the first draw, much less for the following ones. A deep part is therefore made in several draws.
Wrinkles
In the flange, the material is compressed as it flows towards the punch. If the blank holder does not restrain it enough, it buckles and wrinkles. Blank holder pressure is increased, the blank shape adjusted or draw beads added.
Tears
Conversely, material held back too much stretches until it breaks, often near the punch radius. Too much depth in one draw, sharp radii and poor lubrication are the causes. The strain is spread over more draws and radii are softened.
Work hardening and annealing
Austenitic stainless steel hardens strongly with each deformation. Beyond a certain number of draws it loses ductility: intermediate annealing restores its drawability.
Earing
Sheet metal does not have exactly the same properties in every direction. The rim of a round drawn part then shows regular waves, called ears. They are removed by trimming.
Springback
Once out of the tool, the part recovers part of its shape. The tool is corrected to compensate, and a restrike operation sets the final dimensions.
Scratches and galling
Stainless steel tends to stick to tools. Tool polishing, surface treatments, suitable lubricants and protective film on the sheet preserve the appearance, essential for a mirror-polished part.
The engineering office's role
Most of these defects are anticipated at the design stage: simulation, choice of radii, number of draws, grade and thickness. In Vire, our engineering office and toolmakers design the tools in-house.
Can a wrinkle be fixed?
Not on the part: the tool or settings are corrected, and the defective part is rejected.
Is simulation enough?
It guides the design; tool trials confirm the result.
Information for a quote
Send the part drawing, grade, thickness, expected finish and volumes. We will tell you the drawing sequence we envisage.